| Singles competition |
| 1. Jack Schiro (CARTHAGE) vs. Cooper Payne (WCMT) 6-1, 5-2, unfinished |
| 2. Sammy Ramoni (CARTHAGE) vs. Andrew Darkow (WCMT) 6-4, 0-1, unfinished |
| 3. J.T. Delk (CARTHAGE) vs. Chris Claypool (WCMT) 6-2, 0-1, unfinished |
| 4. Matt Whiteside (CARTHAGE) vs. Josh Brown (WCMT) 6-1, 4-3, unfinished |
| 5. Andy Schwenke (CARTHAGE) def. David Berry (WCMT) 6-1, 6-1 |
| 6. Alex McLean (CARTHAGE) def. Justin Arnold (WCMT) 6-0, 6-2 |
| Doubles competition |
| 1. Sammy Ramoni/J.T. Delk (CARTHAGE) def. Chris Claypool/Cooper Payne (WCMT) 9-7 |
| 2. Jack Schiro/Matt Whiteside (CARTHAGE) def. Andrew Darkow/Josh Brown (WCMT) 8-3 |
| 3. Andy Schwenke/Alex McLean (CARTHAGE) def. David Berry/Patrick Duffy (WCMT) 8-6 |
| Match Notes |
| Westminster (Mo.) 13-7 |
| Carthage College 18-6 |
| Order of finish: Doubles (2,3,1); Singles (6,5) |
| 2009 NCAA Men's Tennis Central Region Quarterfinals. |