| Singles competition |
| 1. #3 John Watts (WASHU) def. #6 Michael Greenberg (KENM) 6-2, 7-5 |
| 2. Tomas Piskacek (KENM) def. #12 Charlie Cutler (WASHU) 6-2, 3-6, 10-7 |
| 3. Max Woods (WASHU) def. Jeremy Polster (KENM) 6-1, 4-6, 10-6 |
| 4. Isaac Stein (WASHU) def. Charles Brody (KENM) 6-4, 6-2 |
| 5. Danny Levy (WASHU) def. William VandenBerg (KENM) 6-3, 7-5 |
| 6. Slavi Fildish (WASHU) def. Daniel Becker (KENM) 3-6, 6-4, 10-6 |
| Doubles competition |
| 1. #3 Charlie Cutler/Chris Hoeland (WASHU) def. Michael Greenberg/William VandenBerg (KENM) 8-6 |
| 2. #8 Isaac Stein/Max Woods (WASHU) def. Daniel Becker/Charles Brody (KENM) 8-5 |
| 3. John Watts/Nirmal Choradia (WASHU) def. Jeremy Polster/Tomas Piskacek (KENM) 8-4 |
| Match Notes |
| Kenyon College 5-2; National ranking #8 |
| Washington University 2-1; National ranking #1 |
| Order of finish: Doubles (2,1,3); Singles (5,4,1,3,2,6) |
| 2009 ITA Division III National Team Indoor Championship First Semifinals |